Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

xocetaceans

(4,286 posts)
23. That's probably because of the fundamental asymmetries in biology and how those impact sports.
Thu Apr 20, 2023, 12:08 PM
Apr 2023

There is no similar case corresponding to that of Lia Thomas. So, there is no sense of unfairness relating to your question which has been created in public opinion for the GOP to exploit.

Are there any trans-gendered men who have successfully taken any titles away from cis-gendered men? I don't know of any. Even if there were, the "ethos" around that sort of a defeat would have the public tell those who were defeated to "suck it up, losers!" At least, that is my guess. Then, if further complaints were encountered, it would quickly descend into an imitation of the bully from The Simpson's and "Ha! Ha! You were beaten by a girl!" would be expressed.

One of the problems with this whole issue is that it depends on a similar sense of fairness existing on both sides of the debate. It is not going to work out for Democrats politically to expect the GOP to mirror of the Democrats' sense of fairness on this issue.

If the Democrats make this a primary issue, they will likely lose independents in the next election in spite of everything the GOP has done to destroy women's rights.

So, to answer your question more succinctly, there is nothing to be gained by the GOP if they were to do what you suggest in your question, while there is a lot to be lost for the Democrats in opposing this issue.

The primary issue related to this topic should be one of healthcare and ensuring that all people have access to healthcare. To allow this to be made into an issue about sports does not serve the Democrats well.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

House passes anti-trans sports bill [View all] BumRushDaShow Apr 2023 OP
Well there's some time well spent underpants Apr 2023 #1
I like the tweet I saw yesterday: Initech Apr 2023 #15
From stories over the last few weeks underpants Apr 2023 #18
So fucking stupid, and I really hope their asses get sued over this. Initech Apr 2023 #31
Do you know. . FarPoint Apr 2023 #2
Am waiting on the Roll Call to be posted online BumRushDaShow Apr 2023 #3
Roll call is up - no (D) votes for it BumRushDaShow Apr 2023 #5
Thank you so much FarPoint Apr 2023 #12
Most welcome! BumRushDaShow Apr 2023 #13
I hate these headlines that say "House Passes..." when it should say "Republicans in House pass..." Midnight Writer Apr 2023 #37
Here's my stupid question: why do all the GQP bills only ban trans women/girls sinkingfeeling Apr 2023 #4
Same question. Traildogbob Apr 2023 #6
First thing I thought of as well Bayard Apr 2023 #21
That's probably because of the fundamental asymmetries in biology and how those impact sports. xocetaceans Apr 2023 #23
I don't believe it's a 'losing issue ' for Democrats. People, of every stripe, are sinkingfeeling Apr 2023 #26
They never rose to the level of creating a question of fairness for the following reasons... xocetaceans Apr 2023 #33
Probably due to the changes proposed in the context of Title IX laws MichMan Apr 2023 #27
Everyday Americans are being killed in senseless gun violence murders in this country but the kimbutgar Apr 2023 #7
They found the "abortion issue" was a losing strategy for them BumRushDaShow Apr 2023 #9
How many cases are there of trans athletes that the average American would come in contact with? kimbutgar Apr 2023 #10
Exactly! BumRushDaShow Apr 2023 #14
Greedy old perverts gravitate to ... sanatanadharma Apr 2023 #8
Fuck these asshole MAGA conspiracy theory lunatics. Initech Apr 2023 #11
They can't legislate, so they fan culture wars Novara Apr 2023 #16
Pedophiles BumRushDaShow Apr 2023 #19
It's fucking sick Novara Apr 2023 #24
Exactly BumRushDaShow Apr 2023 #25
It won't pass, fortunately, but if it did it would mean Ocelot II Apr 2023 #17
Why wouldn't a trans woman be allowed to compete on a boy's team ? MichMan Apr 2023 #30
Chum for the base. sarcasmo Apr 2023 #20
Asleep people might become woke IronLionZion Apr 2023 #22
Next week the house will take up the urgent issue of unicorns farting gold dust. Ray Bruns Apr 2023 #28
Yeah here's the crazy thing about this. Initech Apr 2023 #32
When they'e supposed to fart rainbows Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Apr 2023 #35
Title IX is already inherently flawed in execution MichMan Apr 2023 #29
"Who cares about the debt limit?" The GOPee Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin Apr 2023 #34
If you aren't them Marthe48 Apr 2023 #36
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»House passes anti-trans s...»Reply #23