Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Celerity

(52,504 posts)
14. Why should it offend them? Is their belief so weak that critique or criticism of any or all
Fri Jul 21, 2023, 10:46 PM
Jul 2023

religions (or, as in my case, a more foundational critique of the wilful suspension of disbelief that is necessary to believe in a god or gods at all, regardless of any particular religion) causes them to have to lash out and demand all critique/criticism be silenced and suppressed?

You are falsely equating logical critique of a belief system (and if that belief system is god or gods-based, a critique of the epistemological underpinnings necessary to believe in said supernatural beings/concepts) with somehow a priori attacking Democrats.

You brought up a fictional character, Tinker Bell. If you actually DID believe that Tinker Bell is real, then, to arrive at that stance, you would have to apply the exact same wilful suspension of disbelief that people use in order to believe in a god or gods. You have no problem (I assume) with people critiquing a person who claims Tinker Bell is real, yet you then pivot to a stance of condemnation and false equivalency when another person uses that exact same logic to critique religion and its often attendant god or gods.

A simpler way to put it: If you understand why you dismiss the possibility (again, assuming you do) that Tinker Bell, the Easter Bunny or other mythical/fictional beings are indeed real, then you will see why non believers dismiss the concepts of a god or gods as well.

They are all human-created inventions that require magical/supernatural thinking (ie the wilful suspension of disbelief) to claim they exist.

A declaration by a non god(s) believing person stating that they refuse to engage in a wilful suspension of disbelief, and then stating why they chose not to, is hardly an attack when it is not made directly personal, but is just merely stated as their stance on the matters at hand.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

How do Santa Claus and the Tooth Fairy rate ? nt eppur_se_muova Jul 2023 #1
I'd wager they rate more poorly ... though objectively I'm not exactly sure why (nt) Hugh_Lebowski Jul 2023 #2
what percent believe in the Pillsbury Dough Boy? DBoon Jul 2023 #3
What % are saying they believe because it's expected and they're hedging? maxsolomon Jul 2023 #4
Lucifer isn't exactly in good graces. keithbvadu2 Jul 2023 #5
Similarly, more believe in heaven than in hell. yardwork Jul 2023 #15
This is why I cringe when our fringe calls God Tinker-bell or pwb Jul 2023 #6
Atheists are good Democrats, too. maxsolomon Jul 2023 #10
I have no problem with that. pwb Jul 2023 #11
Who bad mouths atheists??? yardwork Jul 2023 #17
Atheism is still a taboo for American politicians Celerity Jul 2023 #22
Why should it offend them? Is their belief so weak that critique or criticism of any or all Celerity Jul 2023 #14
Thank you. yardwork Jul 2023 #16
Good Democrats or not.... Happy Hoosier Jul 2023 #24
I 100% believe in the chair I'm sitting on. Solly Mack Jul 2023 #7
Brilliant! Solomon Jul 2023 #8
I don't believe in any of those things nevergiveup Jul 2023 #9
Too bad you didn't have a cell phone back then. Sky Jewels Jul 2023 #20
I Believe NowISeetheLight Jul 2023 #12
It's not the god of the Bible. Sky Jewels Jul 2023 #19
Agreed NowISeetheLight Jul 2023 #23
Right. Sky Jewels Jul 2023 #25
Contact NowISeetheLight Jul 2023 #26
Played by Mathew McConaughey. What a cool movie written my Carl Segan. nt Prairie_Seagull Jul 2023 #27
Different Guy NowISeetheLight Jul 2023 #29
I sit corrected. He does look like Reed. Thanks Prairie_Seagull Jul 2023 #30
Even the Names NowISeetheLight Jul 2023 #31
This message was self-deleted by its author Celerity Jul 2023 #13
WTF?! It's that high?! Sky Jewels Jul 2023 #18
Far too many say they believe "just in case there's one hiding out there somewhere".... KY_EnviroGuy Jul 2023 #21
Thanks for this. I mis-understood the word. nt Prairie_Seagull Jul 2023 #28
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Belief in Five Spiritual ...»Reply #14