Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

PoindexterOglethorpe

(28,150 posts)
16. Serious physicists and astronomers do not believe
Thu Mar 3, 2022, 11:02 PM
Mar 2022

that FTL (faster than light) drive will ever be possible. And don't bother invoking "a species millions of years more advanced" to get to FTL. For one thing, species generally don't live that long. Evolution is ongoing. And the speed of light really is a fixed and inviolable limit.

The whole SETI thing (search for extra-terrestrial intelligence) is a total waste of time. If we actually were to capture and decode something from a distance place in our galaxy, the odds are extremely high that they will be long extinct by the time we hear from them.

Something else to keep in mind. According to My Son The Astronomer, when you get close to the center of the galaxy, there is a LOT more radiation which is not particularly conducive to life as we know it. If there are other intelligent life forms out there, they will probably tend to be on the fringes of our galaxy, as we are. And those on the exact opposite side are at least 50,000 or so light years away.

Something else about SETI. It assumes broadcasting signals. Right now, on this planet, we are broadcasting far less than we did even a few decades ago, because we've gone to sending signals directly to satellites which bounce them back the local towers for the cable providers. Not much is going out into space. Plus, SETI is looking at a wavelength we've NEVER used to broadcast signals, which I find rather bizarre.

There's also the issue of radiation once you get outside the protection of this planet. I strongly recommend How to Die in Space by Paul M. Sutter. It will make you utterly committed to saving this planet.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Maybe leftieNanner Feb 2022 #1
No doubt about it Bayard Feb 2022 #2
Yep, considering how long it takes now for our missions to explore the outer planets.. brush Feb 2022 #5
Warp drive would only be useful for short hops. For longer ones such as cstanleytech Feb 2022 #10
This is why I'm so impatient wryter2000 Feb 2022 #3
reaching other Galaxies at the speed of light R0ckyRac00n Feb 2022 #13
Thanks wryter2000 Feb 2022 #14
Thanks :) R0ckyRac00n Feb 2022 #15
So, I guess we should pack a lunch, huh? rsdsharp Feb 2022 #4
and how many generations of people...hmm nt msongs Feb 2022 #6
Maybe make a video of it I_UndergroundPanther Feb 2022 #7
A parallel and very sobering issue is to convert those distances into travel times... RockRaven Feb 2022 #8
Please once we make the jump to hyperspace we will be there in 2 shakes of a lamb's tail Botany Feb 2022 #9
I think that's why the logic ymetca Feb 2022 #11
Great moniss Feb 2022 #12
Serious physicists and astronomers do not believe PoindexterOglethorpe Mar 2022 #16
But it is comforting to think that... Kablooie Mar 2022 #17
In reality, the signals degrade rather quickly. PoindexterOglethorpe Mar 2022 #19
Well, if the infinite multiverse theory is correct... Kablooie Mar 2022 #20
AI robotics is a possible alternative to organic life closer to the galactic core NickB79 Mar 2022 #18
Unless there is someway to break Einstein's law SCantiGOP Mar 2022 #21
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science»Visualizing how far we mu...»Reply #16