Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

snot

(11,889 posts)
14. Why are the destruction of our speech & privacy rights so favored as solutions of first resort?
Tue Jun 9, 2026, 06:58 PM
Tuesday

The only way this can be implemented is if one or more of the following are required:

You must verify your age by linking your digital devices to your ID.

You must allow the government – or whatever private third-party agency the government employs – access to your devices' data and files at all times.

You must allow third-party software to scan every attempted photo.

Note that these requirements would effectively apply to users everywhere, not just within the UK. Is this really just about protecting children?

Instead of decimating the privacy of every single person who uses the internet, and given the growing consensus regarding the harms to children from unlimited social media use, why not instead simply require phone and computer manufacturers to offer a parental control on phones and computers that enables parents to block access to social media, forums, chat rooms, and the like, while also requiring such platforms to identify themselves in a way that would facilitate such blocking. The control could include a feature allowing parents to designate particular exceptions to the block for sites that the parent trusts, e.g., if there were a school-related forum or chat room.

And I have to think that other approaches are also possible that wouldn't require the wholesale destruction of individual privacy rights; e.g., public education campaigns to make parents and children more aware of dangers, or simply outlawing phones for kids (I grew up just fine without one).

Recommendations

2 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

If Trump is against it... them I'm all for it. QueerDuck Tuesday #1
... 2naSalit Tuesday #2
One of my all time favorites! 😂🤣👍️ QueerDuck Tuesday #3
I suspected... 2naSalit Tuesday #4
From the same people who cheered (after demanding) schools ban cell phones. Grins Wednesday #24
This is one of the few areas Matthew28 Tuesday #5
I really want to agree with you... and I appreciate where you're coming from... slightlv Tuesday #8
Thank you for this reply. LiberalLovinLug Tuesday #21
"Freedom of speech" is assessed somewhat differently in the UK 0rganism Tuesday #9
This message was self-deleted by its author Skittles Tuesday #15
The only problem is: oberle Tuesday #16
Ohhhhh, poor US tech firms! City Lights Tuesday #6
With Kissin Kousin Eppy gone, the current White House resident needs other ways to recruit those under 16 for his sons. Wonder Why Tuesday #7
Apparently youngsters take social media seriously. Aussie105 Tuesday #10
Don't care about tech firms' woes. In the end, they'll adapt for a dollar, I'm sure. OC375 Tuesday #11
Social media isn't healthy for a lot of people. ForgoTheConsequence Tuesday #12
The real concern is the potential cutting off of the brainwashing of children to accept the status quo. cstanleytech Tuesday #13
Why are the destruction of our speech & privacy rights so favored as solutions of first resort? snot Tuesday #14
What makes him think the UK is going to listen to him? On ANYTHING! JustKay Tuesday #17
This is icky. Baitball Blogger Tuesday #18
None of your business, asshole. LudwigPastorius Tuesday #19
When the fuck did it become acceptable for them to keep trying to influence policies that affect the EU? Karasu Tuesday #20
What a shame if our children were isolated from a constant flood of fascist propaganda..... KY_EnviroGuy Tuesday #22
They want to poison the minds of everyone, everywhere! The younger the better! PSPS Wednesday #23
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»White House urges UK not ...»Reply #14