Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

sl8

(16,927 posts)
38. Why does Mexican Coke taste different than American Coke (it's not the sugar type)
Wed Oct 22, 2025, 01:36 PM
Wednesday

This seemed like a good time to repost this. Basically, there's no differences in the types of sugar present in the Coke some weeks after the soda is bottled, regardless of whether it was made with cane sugar or HFCS (any sucrose used becomes free fructose and glucose). There are some other differences in the ingredients (e.g., salt or sodium) other than the sugar used that might account for some taste differences.

==================

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4285619/

[...]

Ventura et al.4 found no inconsistencies in HFCS-sweetened beverages, but did report discrepancies between types of sugars claimed on product labels and those detected in sucrose-sweetened beverages. However, their sucrose concern was almost certainly a failure to consider acid-catalyzed sucrose inversion to free fructose and glucose, a well-characterized phenomenon known to occur in the low-pH environment of most carbonated beverages (and a host of other acidic foods and beverages). Thus, concern about types of sugars in HFCS- and sucrose-sweetened beverages appears to be based on incomplete understanding of sugars chemistry in carbonated beverages.

[...]



9:55 min.



Everyone is Wrong About Mexican Coke ( Even ‪@johnnyharris )

Reactions
Dec 11 2024

A 2011 paper found that Mexican Coke – which is supposed to be sweetened with cane sugar – contained no cane sugar. Instead, the paper found plenty of glucose and fructose: the main ingredients in high fructose corn syrup. Could Coke be lying to us all? Or is there another, even stranger explanation?

Correction: 0:51 Cu2O is copper(I) oxide, not copper(II) oxid

Credits:
Executive Producer:
Matthew Radcliff

Producers:
Andrew Sobey
Elaine Seward
Darren Weaver

Writers:
George Zaidan

Hosts:
George Zaidan

Scientific Consultants:
John Richardson, Ph.D.
Jeb Kegerreis, Ph.D.

Executive in Charge for PBS: Maribel Lopez
Director of Programming for PBS: Gabrielle Ewing
Assistant Director of Programming for PBS: John Campbell

Reactions is a production of the American Chemical Society.
© 2024 American Chemical Society. All rights reserved

[...]



List of sources provided at link.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Coke made with cane sugar has a completely different taste. Irish_Dem Wednesday #1
You are crazy, lol hueymahl Wednesday #2
Yes of course. All addictions are crazy. Irish_Dem Wednesday #6
McDonalds has special Coke? IronLionZion Wednesday #21
Fountains don't just pour sodas, they create a product from raw ingredients. unblock Wednesday #26
This makes sense. And the McDonald carbonation strength and quantity is amazing. Irish_Dem Wednesday #59
McDonalds is allowed to change the ratio of syrup to carbonated water (and they do). Angleae Wednesday #46
Yes I can tell which McD franchise screws around like this. Irish_Dem Wednesday #61
I don't know. All I know is that the coke tastes different depending upon source. Irish_Dem Wednesday #58
Hey I_D popsdenver Wednesday #36
Amazing isn't it? The pay for play and corruption. Irish_Dem Wednesday #62
Some of the Mexican Cokes I have drunk have a "dirty" kind of taste, like a little dirt got caught in it. LiberalArkie Wednesday #10
If I remember correctly, the CEO of the baby formula Ilsa Wednesday #47
melamine kiri Wednesday #53
It has been a while, but that was what my old memory remembered. But it may have been the first report. LiberalArkie Wednesday #55
Exactly! It's why I can stomach UK Coca Cola. mwooldri Wednesday #16
Yep, the "New Coke" was a dirty trick by CocaCola to slip in HFCS... IthinkThereforeIAM Wednesday #33
Interesting. ShazzieB Wednesday #42
I personally know, back from my drinking days... IthinkThereforeIAM Yesterday #70
Weeks after bottling the sucrose has become glucose and fructose, the same as in HFCS. sl8 Wednesday #43
Yep - both sides of the spectrum are equally misinformed here FreeState Wednesday #49
"New Coke" was the 80s. ShazzieB Wednesday #37
There is a Mexican burrito place not too far away from me. They have Mexican coke. It's great SupportSanity Wednesday #51
It's weird. The best Coke I've had AFTER Mexican Coke TlalocW Wednesday #54
You're both crazy :) Polybius Wednesday #56
You probably don't want to hear my criticisms of Dairy Queen Ice Cream from store to store. Irish_Dem Wednesday #63
It does have a different taste. markodochartaigh Wednesday #4
Cane sugar ruins the experience. Irish_Dem Wednesday #8
Well, I prefer root beer anyway. markodochartaigh Wednesday #9
Yes root beer is nice. Not addictive however? Irish_Dem Wednesday #13
I hardly drink soda, but ... sleroy49 Wednesday #41
Food is personal preference. To each their own. Irish_Dem Wednesday #60
Most Americans under 50 have never tried "old" Coke with real cane sugar FakeNoose Wednesday #66
I think the old old coke was actually made with real cocaine? Irish_Dem Wednesday #67
It was an ingredient at one time, but it was removed long ago FakeNoose Wednesday #68
Coke was made with cocaine from coca leaves until 1903. Irish_Dem Wednesday #69
I've gotta say JBTaurus83 Wednesday #3
the real news is the orange asshole is bullying a corporation. Javaman Wednesday #5
And the corporation is bending the knee BumRushDaShow Wednesday #12
Why do corps bend the knee to Trump so easily? SpankMe Wednesday #39
I think that many of them get to some "steady state" existence BumRushDaShow Wednesday #44
Just add this to the list popsdenver Wednesday #48
That famous monlogue in the film "Network" nailed it 50 years ago! BumRushDaShow Wednesday #52
He'll have them making the cane sugar Coke slightlv Wednesday #28
HE doesn't even drink that BumRushDaShow Wednesday #45
How is the taste using Michigan beet sugar? multigraincracker Wednesday #7
Probably the same wolfie001 Wednesday #14
No coke is the best coke angrycaveman Wednesday #11
I drink 1-2 Diet Cokes per month wolfie001 Wednesday #15
Pepsi! BumRushDaShow Wednesday #22
But King Donald proclaimed that it would happen, so it did happen. tanyev Wednesday #17
King Donald should be suing the company... llmart Wednesday #18
Trump can't keep his ugly snout... GiqueCee Wednesday #19
This should be make American corn farmers happy ... Auggie Wednesday #20
No coke. Pepsi. JustABozoOnThisBus Wednesday #23
I will always miss Gilda. Belushi too but Gilda was so wonderful in every way. Thanks. twodogsbarking Wednesday #29
Shouldn't he be presidenting? N/t hoosierspud Wednesday #24
I was upset this morning, thinking about what Orange-Nut-Job has done to OUR Whitehouse... chouchou Wednesday #25
My theory is that the glass bottle vs aluminum can makes more of a difference than sugar vs. hfcs unblock Wednesday #27
Adjusting the carbonization levels changes the taste. More addiction. twodogsbarking Wednesday #30
Coke? Don't tell Rubio. He and Hegseth will order a military strike Raven123 Wednesday #31
Both sugar and cane sugar are unhealthy. I don't drink any soda so I could care less. appleannie1 Wednesday #32
Mescaline would be a good additive. Real magic. It's the surreal thing. Better thanAI. twodogsbarking Wednesday #34
Either way YUK! North Coast Lawyer Wednesday #35
Why does Mexican Coke taste different than American Coke (it's not the sugar type) sl8 Wednesday #38
The Coke thing is a distraction. Aussie105 Wednesday #65
LOL I thought Republicans were all about the free market. LudwigPastorius Wednesday #40
WHO GIVES A FUCK!! Cheezoholic Wednesday #50
I thought Trump was anti-Mexican anything n/t Polybius Wednesday #57
One more issue that is totally beyond his jurisdiction Rhiannon12866 Wednesday #64
Agree there is a meaningful difference between can sugar Coke and HFCS coke, but even more important: OrwellwasRight 14 hrs ago #71
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Trump's plan to improve C...»Reply #38