Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Drum

(10,301 posts)
28. Let's dispel the notion the ship was trying to sail under the bridge. They weren't and wouldn't.
Sun May 18, 2025, 09:58 AM
9 hrs ago

The NYTimes says that they left Pier 17 and were to motor South into N.Y. Harbor “with a stop on the Brooklyn waterfront to refuel before heading onward to Iceland. Instead, at about 8:30 p.m., the Cuauhtémoc was apparently headed in the wrong direction, never intending to sail under the Brooklyn Bridge, said a spokesman for the city’s Office of Emergency Management.”

Information will emerge in the investigation. In the meantime please resist the pulse to scold. These are real sailors, under competent command, and I think it’s more of a mechanical failure than anything. I can’t believe it was a mistake in navigation or anything like that. To a sailor or boater, a huge priority is always to be sure of clearances and to avoid the terrible event of colliding with anything.

I live on Roosevelt Island n NYC, smack in the centerline of the East River, and the waters and tide flows are quite powerful, reversing several times daily. It’s a big challenge for boaters. Will be following this closely!

Recommendations

4 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Countdown till Trump declares this an act of war by Mexico SledDriver 20 hrs ago #1
Gawd, I hope trump doesn't declare war on Mexico. Watching on news, tops of the masts broke off. The bridge appears OK. Silent Type 20 hrs ago #2
He'll probably settle for having the crew arrested generalbetrayus 20 hrs ago #5
No joke. I sure hope we have proper guidelines for handling a ceremonial foreign ship. Silent Type 20 hrs ago #9
We don't need no stinking SCantiGOP 19 hrs ago #16
Rigging is heavy BidenRocks 20 hrs ago #3
The ship was damaged? How about the bridge? nt babylonsister 20 hrs ago #4
Orange Julius Caesar will increase the tariffs on Mexican goods generalbetrayus 20 hrs ago #8
That's exactly what he will do ribrepin 18 hrs ago #18
It's still standing. I'm sure there is some damage, but could be minor. It was like the top 1/5th of masts. Silent Type 20 hrs ago #11
Initial reports on FB said the GP6971 20 hrs ago #6
Fascinating PJMcK 20 hrs ago #7
I believe the ship lost power -- I don't think the skipper intentionally tried to sail under the bridge. LauraInLA 6 hrs ago #33
You're correct PJMcK 32 min ago #36
Sal is talking about it on What's Going on with Shipping on Youtube. bluedigger 20 hrs ago #10
Shocking how the captain didn't estimate the height of the masts.... wolfie001 20 hrs ago #12
I believe the ship lost power or something and the skipper couldn't control it. LauraInLA 6 hrs ago #34
Thank you wolfie001 4 hrs ago #35
Scary FelineOverlord 19 hrs ago #13
Stuck in reverse RoseTrellis 11 hrs ago #24
More video FelineOverlord 19 hrs ago #14
Beautiful tall mast ship. So sorry to hear AllyCat 19 hrs ago #15
Sorry about the source canetoad 18 hrs ago #17
MAGAs: "Remember the Brooklyn Bridge!" C Moon 17 hrs ago #19
Yeah, trump is probably still coming in his pants over this. (nt) Paladin 10 hrs ago #26
AP: Mexican tall ship strikes Brooklyn Bridge, snapping masts and killing 2 crew members riversedge 17 hrs ago #20
Oh no Kali 7 hrs ago #31
I hear the ship lost power prior to impact. BidenRocks 17 hrs ago #21
🚨 A Mexican Navy training ship, the Cuauhtmoc, built in Spain in 1982, crashed into the Brooklyn Bridge riversedge 16 hrs ago #22
Someone dropped the ball... GiqueCee 11 hrs ago #23
I trim my trees before I drive under the Brooklyn Bridge. 🙂 Wonder Why 10 hrs ago #25
Two dead as Mexican Navy ship crashes into Brooklyn Bridge Eugene 9 hrs ago #27
Let's dispel the notion the ship was trying to sail under the bridge. They weren't and wouldn't. Drum 9 hrs ago #28
Mexico is like here's payment for your border wall, take that IronLionZion 7 hrs ago #29
Sabotage. k_buddy762 7 hrs ago #30
Mexican Navy AzTired64 6 hrs ago #32
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Mexican Navy ship crashes...»Reply #28