Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Lonestarblue

(13,016 posts)
10. I stopped being against it a long time ago. It's the only way to save our democracy.
Tue Sep 6, 2022, 12:53 PM
Sep 2022

The federal courts and the Supreme Court all need an overhaul. The circuit courts have actually needed an overhaul for years because of workload issues. I think these courts were last adjusted when the US had a population of around 220 million. Our population is now over 330 million and population shifts have changed the workloads for several courts, making cases take years for resolution, sometimes more than five years, which is not justice.

We most likely need more justices on some circuit courts and perhaps fewer or no changes on others, such as those that cover rural states that have lost population. We might even need to add a couple of new circuit courts to balance the populations covered.

As for the Supreme Court, they have been doing far too much ruling through docket cases, partially because they take so few cases for full review. I believe the court should be expanded to 13 justices—one for each of our 13 federal circuit courts. Even if the number of circuit courts is expanded, one justice could most likely handle two of the courts with less populous states rather than expanding the SC to 15.

Obviously, we need the House and Senate to do this, and if we keep the majority it needs to happen next year to give time for a bunch of new appointments. I remember reading some time ago that an analysis of the workloads in some of the busiest circuit courts had already been made (not the one Biden ordered), with requests for additional justices. I’m sure each of those courts has an idea for how many justices they need.

The will to do this by Congress is a big question mark.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Another part of the plot by the RW Christofascists, including those at SCOTUS, to destroy democracy. lark Sep 2022 #1
yeah, they almost got it GenXer47 Sep 2022 #6
Welcome to DU. lark Sep 2022 #7
LOL. "controversial" PSPS Sep 2022 #2
He is the son of Bush administration, John Ashcroft karynnj Sep 2022 #3
The name did seem familiar DFW Sep 2022 #20
The controversy is only coming from one side, and it's the fucking crazy one. Initech Sep 2022 #4
Time to add FOUR MORE SCOTUS Justices! I used to be against this idea, but not now! n/t TeamProg Sep 2022 #5
Do they actually believe the American people would be OK with this? fightforfreedom Sep 2022 #8
Considering the SCOTUS approval is at an all time low ColinC Sep 2022 #11
A Dem Senate majority may be able to IMPEACH the five liars: Thomas, Kavanaugh, Barrett, Gorsuch & TeamProg Sep 2022 #13
Barrett didn't lie Polybius Sep 2022 #16
It would be easier to just add seats ColinC Sep 2022 #18
Bullshit. intheflow Sep 2022 #17
Yup ColinC Sep 2022 #19
I stopped being against it a long time ago. It's the only way to save our democracy. Lonestarblue Sep 2022 #10
No not now Polybius Sep 2022 #15
Societies need rules and organization, not chaos bucolic_frolic Sep 2022 #9
oh lord, this is goddamed scary vlyons Sep 2022 #12
Self government is coming to an end in America . geretogo Sep 2022 #14
If you cannot win under the original legitimate rules make up your own and claim they apply. Ford_Prefect Sep 2022 #21
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Missouri secretary of sta...»Reply #10