General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Elizabeth Warren Humiliates Mitch McConnell For Threat To Block Obama SCOTUS Nominee [View all]21st Century Poet
(255 posts)Elizabeth Warren is right that President Obama has a mandate to appoint a nominee to the Supreme Court but the Republicans are right in saying that there is no obligation for the Senate to accept the appointment.
The President has a right to appoint a Supreme Court Judge.
The Senate has a right to reject the appointment.
It's right there in what Elizabeth Warren herself said: "With the advice and consent of the Senate".
What the Republicans are saying is not unconstitutional. The Senate has a right to refuse the appointment. Whether it is morally the right thing to do to leave Scalia's seat vacant for almost a year is another matter altogether.
Let's face it. Had the situation been the other way round with a Republican President in his last year trying to appoint a Judge to the Supreme Court, a Senate with a Democratic majority would also resist it.
You see, this is the problem with American politics today. You have a president and senate majority from opposing parties and the chasms between them are so wide that it is surprising that anything ever gets done. America either needs a president and Senate majority from the same party or more bipartisanship for stuff to work.
Edit history
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):