Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

Divernan

(15,480 posts)
Sat Jul 4, 2015, 08:21 AM Jul 2015

The DARPA Robotics Challenge Was a Bust [View all]

A scientist friend connected with Carnegie-Mellon's Robotics program just posted this link on her FB page, and it was all new to me. When I think of the vast "news" coverage about butt implants & the Kardashians, compared to the scintilla of coverage of this event - well, Einstein wept! This article is absolutely fascinating, and gives you a catch-up look at DARPA's efforts with these competitions. Unless you're someone who ridicules science, give it a read!

http://www.popsci.com/darpa-robotics-challenge-was-bust-why-darpa-needs-try-again

It's been close to a month since the DARPA Robotics Challenge (DRC) wrapped up. That's time enough to face facts. The biggest and most well-funded international robotics competition in years was a failure. That doesn't feel good to write. The DRC was a huge undertaking, spanning years and costing millions. The competition had a noble goal—the development of robots that can better respond to disasters—and it attracted many of the world's smartest and most accomplished roboticists.

"Worst of all, it failed to catch or at least hold the attention of the general public. The event was webcast, but not televised. News outlets with a focus on tech and science covered the finals, but not enough to pique the interest of more mainstream media. Years of work and tens of millions of funding culminated in an event that no one appeared to care about, despite the fact that it featured walking, driving, tool-grabbing humanoid robots.

"This is a shamelessly unscientific survey, but no one among my family or friends knew that the DRC Finals were happening. That includes my brother, who works at NASA, and my 11-year-old nephew, who's in an engineering program sponsored by defense contractor Lockheed Martin, the defense firm that had a team in the DRC. When the competition was over, the only person in my social circle—which is rife with nerds—who had read or seen anything about it was my father-in-law. His sole takeaway: the Pentagon held a contest where a bunch of robots fell down.
"
32 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Shamelessly asking for 5 recs to keep this thread alive. Divernan Jul 2015 #1
Well, if you're going to remain our humble servant... randome Jul 2015 #4
LOL - for brute strength & endurance, it's robots for the win. Divernan Jul 2015 #5
Look, if you can't even get a robot to rec your post don't try to convince us PoliticAverse Jul 2015 #27
My first DU rec is yours pengu Jul 2015 #2
Thank you so much! And welcome to DU! Divernan Jul 2015 #3
Shoutout to mahatmakanejeeves' earlier post which sank like a stone! Divernan Jul 2015 #6
''Horticulture.'' Octafish Jul 2015 #7
Great comment! I'm still apalled at the way science and tech are mostly ignored by the media! LongTomH Jul 2015 #20
Absolutely. As you know, LongTomH, my unrequited flame is the space program... Octafish Jul 2015 #25
If there was a "sex-bot" catagory judged by porn stars the press would be all over it... hunter Jul 2015 #8
My brother does stuff for DARPA DFW Jul 2015 #9
OT, planning to read your book, which comes with high praise. Divernan Jul 2015 #12
Just bought ablamj Jul 2015 #21
Im hoping for some Dr. Whovian "timey-wimey" stuff! Divernan Jul 2015 #22
Well, everybody got something different out of it so far. DFW Jul 2015 #28
Many thanks for taking the time to share all that with us. Divernan Jul 2015 #29
Well, I'm still keeping my day job DFW Jul 2015 #30
I thoroughly enjoyed it. hunter Jul 2015 #32
The rise (and fall) of the machines pscot Jul 2015 #10
So failur as a public spectacle=failure? Adrahil Jul 2015 #11
The OP link makes point that past failures have led to great progress. Divernan Jul 2015 #13
Yeah, i get it. But I'm not a fan of click-bait, misleading headlines. nt Adrahil Jul 2015 #15
Nothing click bait about mag. w/awards for journalistic excellence. Divernan Jul 2015 #16
Yeah, i know and like the mag, i ahted the headline and implication. Adrahil Jul 2015 #17
I agree - yours is a much more positive headline. Divernan Jul 2015 #18
I didn't find out about it until clips from the finals hiy facebook in my social circle. The Animator Jul 2015 #14
My son won the world robotics championship in Singapore a few years ago.... madamvlb Jul 2015 #19
Wow! Most impressive! Belated congratulations! Divernan Jul 2015 #23
Thank you. madamvlb Jul 2015 #24
KnR. nt tblue37 Jul 2015 #26
Thanks for the link. Quackers Jul 2015 #31
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The DARPA Robotics Challe...