Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Moostache

(10,806 posts)
28. AMEN - Social Security is not an entitlement, its the property of the people who paid into it.
Tue Apr 23, 2013, 12:21 AM
Apr 2013

I want to re-frame this debate and reclaim the language into something that actually registers in the shrunken pit of a republican skull - social security PAYMENTS are NOT "benefits" nor are they "entitlements" (at least not in the sense that they get portrayed - something for nothing, or freeloading....if you mean mean money that we are ENTITLED TO HAVE RETURNED, then we can discuss it).

The fact is that progressives and liberals remain on the defense because we lack the collective will to change a meme - ANY meme - that starts off as right wing propaganda.

- We got bullied into the twin wars of Aggression in the 2000's
- We got further bullied into abominations like Gitmo and the Patriot Act just as easily...
- We ended up with a President who negotiates with himself FIRST, then with the opposition and at the end gets nothing he couldn't have had by fiat in the first place.
- We ended up with a Senate Leader who is too timid and weak to take the necessary steps to end the phony gridlock and unconstitutional "60-vote" threshold for even getting VOTES let alone real debate on critical issues.
- We have lost issue after issue after issue because we allow the spin miesters of the right - like that miserable bastard Luntz - to dress them up as something other than what they are and call it something they KNOW will gin up their "base" and create enough noise to seem important.

We have been badly outplayed for a very long time. Its time to stop rolling over, they're just going to kick us again, not rub our belly!

Its NOT "gun control", its "firearm massacre prevention".
Its NOT "Social Security reform", its "returning private equity".
Its NOT "GAY/SAME SEX Marriage", its just "marriage equality".

If the democrats of the 60's and 70's had been as weak as the ones in our representative caucus of today, we wouldn't have had a Civil Rights Movement - it would have been dubbed the "destruction of American Heritage". We would not have passed Civil Rights Legislation - we would have "destroyed the Constitution". In many places in the South, not all, but a good number, you will find EXACTLY these sentiments and worse expounded hourly.

Its time to stop allowing the right to control the language and discussion. Its time to force people to educate themselves and stand up for whats morally courageous, difficult and right instead of whats politically expedient, easy, and cowardly.

Mr. Reid, Mr. Obama, Senators, Representatives, Staffs and others - heed the advice of Mr. Mark Twain and cease to argue with the fools of the right, people WON'T know the difference, and instead start using consistent terminology distinctly different from the professionally crafted right wing lies. TELL THE TRUTH and let its light expose the chicanery and nonsense of the word games they use to bully, bluff and bluster their hateful ideology through to policy.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

She speaks for me!!!!! newfie11 Apr 2013 #1
Agree with the sentiment truebluegreen Apr 2013 #2
I wish I could recommend this more than once. Buns_of_Fire Apr 2013 #3
Social Security SamKnause Apr 2013 #4
Nailed IT! bvar22 Apr 2013 #5
She really should learn to express herself more forcefully. Demoiselle Apr 2013 #6
k & r OldHippieChick Apr 2013 #7
K&r enthusiastically erinlough Apr 2013 #8
please tell me this rightwing excrement is NOT gonna make the front page again hfojvt Apr 2013 #9
Captain Bullshit! Matariki Apr 2013 #10
Check it out at Snopes Playinghardball Apr 2013 #11
I wholeheartedly agree with everything in the post but I believe I xtraxritical Apr 2013 #12
I don't agree with everything Martin Eden Apr 2013 #23
What a toxic POS Simpson is. nt valerief Apr 2013 #13
cool but...isnt this an old letter? rings a bell from a few years back... CarrieLynne Apr 2013 #14
Yep, but they changed a few insignificant things; like the tax cuts to the rich from juajen Apr 2013 #29
a work of pure art!!! beachgirl2365 Apr 2013 #15
Best poetry I have read for ages! asjr Apr 2013 #16
A-freakin'-men! meow2u3 Apr 2013 #17
re: Patty Myers from Montana has a message for Sen. Alan Simpson. allan01 Apr 2013 #18
K&R Couldn't have said it better myself. forestpath Apr 2013 #19
Simpson is a horse's ass Faygo Kid Apr 2013 #20
Spot on Augiedog Apr 2013 #21
HUGE K & R !!! - Thank You !!! WillyT Apr 2013 #22
Eloquent . . . to the point. . . she speaks for me! Liberal In Red State Apr 2013 #24
And for me as well! calimary Apr 2013 #31
it never fails to amaze me hfojvt Apr 2013 #32
He made those comments years ago, didn't he? It was when Simpson-Boles Honeycombe8 Apr 2013 #25
Funny how that works Canuckistanian Apr 2013 #26
Alas, according to Snopes no such woman exists, else I'd try to help her campaign for office... Moonwalk Apr 2013 #27
AMEN - Social Security is not an entitlement, its the property of the people who paid into it. Moostache Apr 2013 #28
i love this post Vietnameravet Apr 2013 #36
Damn, she's good! tex-wyo-dem Apr 2013 #30
address that to obama (and bowles) as well. nt tomp Apr 2013 #33
Address it to him and the rest of the Party Boys in DC and Put My name to it as well!!!!!!!! BillyRibs Apr 2013 #34
Great letter!! nothing I can add to the complements already given.. Vietnameravet Apr 2013 #35
One could compare Alan Simpson to the teats on 310 million mules. Orsino Apr 2013 #37
And I'm sure he considers himself "the greatest generation". AAO Apr 2013 #38
So glad so many others heard Patty Myers zeeland Apr 2013 #39
I am seeing this posted on FB by some with right leanings ... SomeGuyInEagan Apr 2013 #40
K&R Mr. Simpson need to live like the rest of us without insider trading rights... midnight Apr 2013 #41
piss on Alan Simpson KG Apr 2013 #42
Actually I don't mind watoos Apr 2013 #43
As another Montanan WoodyD Apr 2013 #44
KILL THE GRUMPS! emilydickinson Jun 2014 #45
Grups, not Grumps merrily Jun 2014 #46
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Patty Myers from Montana ...»Reply #28