Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: Regarding Courage [View all]

Kid Berwyn

(25,189 posts)
24. The 500
Mon Jun 1, 2026, 03:37 PM
Yesterday

Great news! Hope all in your family are doing well! I hope you get time together to be loved by those you've made possible.

Growing up, I took family for granted. Now that I'm old, I realize why my grandparents emphasized establishing relationships with aunts, uncles, cousins, distant great-aunts, uncle's uncles, third cousins and the rest by marriage. Families, tribes, and villages are the the bedrock on which to build good lives and civilization.

Unfortunately for too many modern generations, the role of the family has also changed, even diminished, with the times. Beleaguered by a crazy world and economic system that rewards greed and predation, no longer are most parents in a position to make life better for the young simply by working harder and longer. Nowadays, big money is needed to make more money. Labor is considered a cost to be minimized.

Speaking of devolution: My wife and I got a free month of Paramount TV and started to watch all the Yellowstone and related programs (1883, 1923, there must be more as we see commercials for new Yellowstone/Taylor Sheridan shows that we hadn't even heard of all the time). I bring it up because Harrison Ford's character explained to the younger generation about "The 500."

Ford's character, the Dutton family patriarch, was describing how in olden times, when humanity lived in familial clans or villages, everyone literally knew everyone else. If one cough teenager like myself was not acting in line with the law and custom, the parents would hear from their cousins or neighbors what was going on. Public pressure backed by parental authority would straighten out the cough teenager out PDQ.

Decision making in the tribe could be accomplished by meeting where all could express opinion and be heard -- and respected -- by everyone else before the group found consensus. When the community grew past the size of 500 people, however, things changed. It became more difficult to know everyone and know where everyone was coming from in a public discussion. Proper behavior no longer was a matter linked to public pressure.

Most importantly: The familial/social contract devolved into the rule of the jungle when the community grew past 500 individuals. Compassion, Cooperation and Consensus devolved into a dynamic of "survival of the fittest" meaning the biggest, meanest and most cruel lorded it over the flock. The strong few eventually became the aristocracy; and the royals made themselves tops by law until 1776.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Regarding Courage [View all] H2O Man Sunday OP
An abundance of embarrassments... kentuck Sunday #1
A lot of corruption, too. H2O Man Sunday #5
We need leaders that understand the gravity of the situation. kentuck Sunday #15
Yes! H2O Man Yesterday #21
K&R MustLoveBeagles Sunday #2
Thank you! H2O Man Sunday #6
We must not assume a return to "normalcy" is orthoclad Sunday #3
Right. H2O Man Sunday #7
When I was a kid, my Mom got a dog and I was tasked with caring for it. Midnight Writer Sunday #4
Interesting. H2O Man Sunday #8
I was lucky. He didn't come around much. Midnight Writer Sunday #10
I, too, was an abused child ... oldsoldierfadingfast Sunday #13
Absolutely! H2O Man Yesterday #18
I, too, was an abused child ... oldsoldierfadingfast Sunday #14
Your story reminds me of Johnny Cash's song Uncle Joe Sunday #11
Ah, my dear H20 Man ... oldsoldierfadingfast Sunday #9
I agree about the USSC. H2O Man Sunday #12
From your lips to God's ear. Joinfortmill Sunday #16
Thanks! H2O Man Yesterday #17
"the members of his party are afraid to honor their oath of office" Martin Eden Yesterday #19
Very good! H2O Man Yesterday #20
The Truly Strong Kid Berwyn Yesterday #22
Thank you! H2O Man Yesterday #23
The 500 Kid Berwyn Yesterday #24
K & R malaise 23 hrs ago #25
Thank you! H2O Man 22 hrs ago #26
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Regarding Courage»Reply #24