General Discussion

sarisataka

(20,670 posts)

15. I am in no position to question their provenance

Wed Oct 9, 2024, 02:05 PM

Oct 9

it is just from the description of what doctors in the US say happens to children shot by assault weapons, these x-rays don't seem to match the descriptions we have been given.

But as I said, I am opposed to targeting children.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

72 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

65 Doctors, Nurses and Paramedics: What We Saw in Gaza (Content: Graphic x-rays) [View all] WhiskeyGrinder Oct 9 OP

unspeakable brutality. WhiteTara Oct 9 #1

War really sucks. Hamas should be completely destroyed for starting it. nt LexVegas Oct 9 #2

Unbelievable response. AloeVera Oct 9 #3

You know, I often push back here on posts from people who say the crime scene photos of mass shootings in the U.S. WhiskeyGrinder Oct 9 #7

The horrible reality of war has been captured on film for well over a hundred years. War has not ended. nt LexVegas Oct 9 #13

+1 BannonsLiver Oct 9 #10

Completely agree DeepWinter 19 hrs ago #53

I'm sure the IDF will conduct an internal investigation Rob H. Oct 9 #4

from the article: WhiskeyGrinder Oct 9 #6

Those snipers will never face consequences Rob H. Oct 9 #8

The IDF are executing children. These are not casualties caused by bombs. Lonestarblue 19 hrs ago #51

Children are being hit by bullets in a war zone is all you can deduce EX500rider 5 min ago #72

But but but malaise Oct 9 #5

But but freedom fighters1!! BannonsLiver Oct 9 #9

Right right. Is it still a-ok to target random Dutch Jews for being Jewish? tritsofme Oct 9 #12

Did someone on this thread target random Dutch Jews for being Jewish?f AloeVera Oct 9 #21

I was just curious if that was still her opinion? tritsofme Oct 9 #24

The x-rays seem odd to my eyes, however sarisataka Oct 9 #11

X-rays provided by doctorcwho worked in Khan Younis: AloeVera Oct 9 #14

I am in no position to question their provenance sarisataka Oct 9 #15

I don't understand your explanation. AloeVera Oct 9 #20

From the description of school shootings sarisataka Oct 9 #22

A trained sniper vs a school shooter? AloeVera Thursday #26

The greatest sniper in the world cannot change physics sarisataka Tuesday #32

Glad to hear it. I'm interested in facts too. AloeVera Tuesday #33

I tend to approach everything from a war sarisataka Tuesday #39

Between 100-300 were killed at al-Ahli hospital AloeVera 17 hrs ago #60

Very unlikely more then a dozen people or so were killed EX500rider 8 hrs ago #68

They're authentic. AloeVera Tuesday #35

It depends on the gun and the caliber obamanut2012 Tuesday #28

A military sniper will be using at least a 5.56mm sarisataka Tuesday #31

I am in the position to question their authenticity. Beastly Boy Oct 9 #17

There is ample evidence iemanja 9 hrs ago #67

Two out of three x-rays don't look authentic at all. Beastly Boy Oct 9 #16

I agree MoseShrute Oct 9 #18

There may be perfectly acceptable explanations why the extent of bullet penetration may not be a factor, Beastly Boy Oct 9 #19

They were authenticated, and there are also photographs of the bodies obamanut2012 Tuesday #30

The images are authentic. AloeVera Tuesday #36

I don't know what prompted this disclaimer, Beastly Boy Tuesday #40

Who is going to stop Iran from arming its terrorist proxies? Beastly Boy Oct 9 #23

Afternoon kick WhiskeyGrinder Oct 9 #25

FWIW: A statement from the NYT editor about the images WhiskeyGrinder Tuesday #27

Thank you obamanut2012 Tuesday #29

Thanks!! No surprise seeing all the aspersions cast in this thread. AloeVera Tuesday #34

Here's an article from Common Dreams published earlier today Rob H. Tuesday #41

The first thing this statement does is call immediate attention to the incompetence of the NYT editor in Beastly Boy Tuesday #42

"The editor repeatedly refers to the images as "CT scans", while the X-ray images included in the article cannot WhiskeyGrinder Yesterday #43

Who are the people you are talking about? Beastly Boy 23 hrs ago #44

OK but "CT scout image" or "scanogram" or "CT localizer" isn't on that indeed minimally informative graphic. WhiskeyGrinder 23 hrs ago #46

If anyone was more informative than this minimally informative data, it didn't register with the author of the rebuttal. Beastly Boy 20 hrs ago #47

You do understand that a CT is merely a compilation of X-rays, Ms. Toad 20 hrs ago #48

It is not merely a compilation of X-rays. Beastly Boy 19 hrs ago #50

You started by suggesting an elementary school child with Photoshop could do a better job of creating fake images Ms. Toad 19 hrs ago #54

I am quibbling about what you are quibbling about, in response to what you are quibbling about. Beastly Boy 18 hrs ago #57

Try actually Googling images of "CT scout scan" Rob H. 19 hrs ago #49

If you are posting an opinion of a professional with extensive experience in image editing, Beastly Boy 19 hrs ago #55

I have time and Photoshop on my side Rob H. 16 hrs ago #61

Slam-dunk. Awesome! N/T. AloeVera 10 hrs ago #64

Thank you kindly :-) nt Rob H. 8 hrs ago #70

So far so good. Beastly Boy 8 hrs ago #69

Thank you. Well-done. AloeVera 18 hrs ago #56

You're very welcome Rob H. 18 hrs ago #59

It is a SCOUT SCAN obamanut2012 19 hrs ago #52

. Beastly Boy 16 hrs ago #62

The only way I see this conflict stopping is if someone could hold both sides apart... DSandra Tuesday #37

"One 4-year-old girl with major burns to her body was completely dissociated. She was staring out into space, humming WhiskeyGrinder Tuesday #38

If these are deliberate acts and not collateral casualties, I hope that those responsible are found and punished. WDLAL 23 hrs ago #45

An interview with Dr. Feroze Sidhwa, the trauma surgeon from Flint, Michigan who wrote the article. Nanjeanne 18 hrs ago #58

Reads like an excerpt from "How to Genocide 101- Special Edition: Success Stories from a Genocide Foretold" AloeVera 13 hrs ago #63

No one would like my view. Xolodno 9 hrs ago #65

Here is a video from CBS' Sunday Morning on this very topic iemanja 9 hrs ago #66

Only way a full metal jacket military sniper round going 2,000mph stops a few inches inside a body.. EX500rider 8 hrs ago #71