Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: Get a load of this crap [View all]
 

ExWhoDoesntCare

(4,741 posts)
30. Hm
Sat Apr 1, 2023, 05:09 PM
Apr 2023

I think I'd split up Asia, because it's both huge in its geography, but also has regions that are quite different from each other, culturally and even sometimes politically (Middle East v the rest of Asia, for instance). So give a seat each to the Middle East, South Asia, and Far East Asia, at a minimum.

Africa also has a rather firm split in its cultural/geographic composition. It would benefit from a division between Northern Africa and the sub-Saharan nations.

Australia & New Zealand could go with Oceania. That's what all those Pacific Island nations are known as these days.

As for Europe, I think the only way to get the current Security Council on board with a shakeup of permanent membership is to make it feasible for both Russia and, say, France or Germany to have permanent status.

The New World could be divided between North America, South America and the Caribbean. As with Africa, Asia and Europe, the interests are different enough between these three sub-regions to justify the split.

The temporary, rotating members could be one other nation in each of the regional memberships. Or some regions could decide that one of them will serve a 5 year term as their "permanent" council representation, and then do a yearly rotation among the remaining nations for the "temporary" member. Let each region decide which type of representation it prefers.

That sort of reorganization would create a Security Council more reflective of the real world as it's stood for quite a while now.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Get a load of this crap [View all] Javaman Apr 2023 OP
The UN has lost its way. Boomerproud Apr 2023 #1
E. Roosevelt would recognize it easily. jaxexpat Apr 2023 #8
That is exactly what they want people to say. edisdead Apr 2023 #29
...K&R... spanone Apr 2023 #2
Actually, they should be expelled from the UN as a Terrorist Nation. Fla Dem Apr 2023 #3
The Nuclear Blackmail Club has its own set of rules. Alexander Of Assyria Apr 2023 #4
is it allowed b/c ukraine is not one of them? (UN) nt orleans Apr 2023 #5
The UN was created under very different conditions after WWII. Lonestarblue Apr 2023 #6
The US also needs a way to punish a rogue state like Russia for waging illegal war against HUAJIAO Apr 2023 #13
Exactly. Nobody was there to stop us from invading/massacring Iraq. Sky Jewels Apr 2023 #25
I for one BumRushDaShow Apr 2023 #14
Hm ExWhoDoesntCare Apr 2023 #30
Well my point was to dump individual "countries" as part of the "5 permanent members" BumRushDaShow Apr 2023 #31
i agree barbtries Apr 2023 #7
I never understood why Russia was given a seat on the security council Victor_c3 Apr 2023 #9
Because... ProfessorGAC Apr 2023 #26
Alarming ⏰ ‼️ If the UN is lost, that's disastrous for the world. live love laugh Apr 2023 #10
It's Russia's turn and can't be helped. These days lots of holes in the laws Hortensis Apr 2023 #11
Trump and Putin have been audits of rule of law and civilized society. Irish_Dem Apr 2023 #19
:) Yes. But tRump's out, and Putin's outnumbered...something to 1. Hortensis Apr 2023 #20
Yes, pass/fail evaluation is a good tool right now. Irish_Dem Apr 2023 #21
But is the world (& esp the US) making necessary changes? NullTuples Apr 2023 #23
Crazy CrayCray thinking. Joinfortmill Apr 2023 #12
Members Dios Mio Apr 2023 #15
The UN has been redundant and impotent for many many years Bev54 Apr 2023 #16
Reminder Russia didn't exist at the time the UN was established it was thr Soviet Union Historic NY Apr 2023 #17
Right and when the user collapsed Javaman Apr 2023 #28
I've thought more than once KentuckyWoman Apr 2023 #18
I like the idea. Much needed and quite useful for this particular job... liberalla Apr 2023 #24
Remember The Simpsons' "Stonecutters" episode? Qutzupalotl Apr 2023 #22
Well, there is NATO, Mr.Bill Apr 2023 #27
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Get a load of this crap»Reply #30