Welcome to DU!
    The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
    Join the community:
    Create a free account
    Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
    Become a Star Member
    Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
    All Forums
        Issue Forums
        Culture Forums
        Alliance Forums
        Region Forums
        Support Forums
        Help & Search
    
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Black man blocked from entering NJ gym where hes a paid member and even the cops are confused [View all]BumRushDaShow
(162,468 posts)160. Here is what the deal is and what you do
        it can't
How can that work?
Trespassing has to remain as it is. Otherwise it becomes toothless as anyone at any time can claim other motivations for their removal from a place.
How can that work?
Trespassing has to remain as it is. Otherwise it becomes toothless as anyone at any time can claim other motivations for their removal from a place.
It's one of the oldest and most pervasive tricks (and charges) in the book to remove black folk from places where whites don't want them. It was a charge that post-de jure segregation laws, allowed the same thing to happen de facto.
This is why the Public Accommodations Act of 1968 specified certain types of facilities where special protection would be provided.
If you are asked to leave go. If it is racist make sure folks know about it and hopefully the business takes a hit as starbucks is.
The owner of a property needs to retain the right remove people from his or her property. How can that be changed to except when...
I just don't see it.
The owner of a property needs to retain the right remove people from his or her property. How can that be changed to except when...
I just don't see it.
Here is the problem - when someone demands "an arrest" based on bogus racist-based charges, and then the lawsuits go flying, it's not just the business that gets hit, it is usually the municipality too because the PD allowed it. And so cities like mine end up paying out MILLIONS of MY tax dollars to settle bullshit cases like what happened with Starbucks because no one bothered to de-escalate a situation and determine that there might have been mitigating factors that precluded any need for "an arrest" (as you see was done with this LA Fitness case). Especially since there was no fighting or property damage or these men harassing other people sitting in the store. In fact the others in there were trying to take up for them but were summarily ignored.
So to go the next step - LA Fitness would get sued big time, but the cops in Secaucus right now are being praised!
Cops should show good judgment and in both of these cases they did in my opinion. Which is refreshing. They spent almost 8 minutes trying to get these guys to leave on their own and they refused. They left the cops with no choice in the situation in my opinion.
The cops did absolute everything wrong in Philly EXCEPT that at least they didn't drag the guys out and slam them on the ground in a choke hold. I.e., their conduct was exemplary. But the officer who took the original call did not ask any details about what was happening (the call was less than 20 seconds). The dispatcher manufactured a major to-do by taking info that said "2 gentlemen refusing to buy anything or leave" to mean "a disruption by a group of men". And because of that, instead of a couple cops showing up, you have an almost "COP DOWN" type of response, with 6-7 showing up with a supervisor. Their negotiation skills and failure to engage witnesses and take witness statements that were contrary to what the manager claimed, is why they failed. And a PERFECT solution presented itself - the "friend" arrived and offered to take them with him to another place and that would be the end of that. But cop ego couldn't handle it and the cop blurted out that it was "too late", killing any chance of resolution other than what has now happened.
Fuck no. NOTHING is "too late".
Now the city is probably going to be on the hook for all kinds of financial compensation as settlement because of some bullshit alpha dog male cop. And Starbucks almost became toast thanks to that decision to arrest, until all this stuff about closing thousands of stores for training and whatnot. But I expect they will still be near-toast for many, just like Denny's.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
  Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
						
							317 replies
							
								 = new reply since forum marked as read
							
						
      
      
					
						Highlight:
						NoneDon't highlight anything
						5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
						RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
 = new reply since forum marked as read
							
						
      
      
					
						Highlight:
						NoneDon't highlight anything
						5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
						RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
					
                    
					
                     = new reply since forum marked as read
							
						
      
      
					
						Highlight:
						NoneDon't highlight anything
						5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
						RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
 = new reply since forum marked as read
							
						
      
      
					
						Highlight:
						NoneDon't highlight anything
						5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
						RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
					
                    
					
                        Black man blocked from entering NJ gym where hes a paid member  and even the cops are confused [View all]
							MrScorpio
							Apr 2018
							OP
                        
        
        White people, we are all complicit in this abuse, one way or the other.
        DemocracyMouse
        Apr 2018
        #229
      
        
        Good thing roles arent reversed , the you know who's would burn down the city
        Eliot Rosewater
        Apr 2018
        #27
      
        
        And the police RIGHTFULLY questioned the manager's account and apparently WERE NOT bound to arrest
        hlthe2b
        Apr 2018
        #6
      
        
        I finally had to put some posters on ignore they were so adamant the Philly police had no choice
        hlthe2b
        Apr 2018
        #17
      
        
        I never said the police were acting in a racist manner.  I said they were derelect in arresting
        hlthe2b
        Apr 2018
        #29
      
        
        I can give you lists too, but I'll simply let you be content with the police force you deserve
        hlthe2b
        Apr 2018
        #45
      
        
        I've made my arguments and am refusing further contact with someone who advocates AGAINST
        hlthe2b
        Apr 2018
        #61
      
        
        Unless YOU are one of those unprofessional type of police officers to which I refer, no insult
        hlthe2b
        Apr 2018
        #75
      
        
        And what if they pretend as in the Starbucks case that it is a non-discriminatory reason but it
        Demsrule86
        Apr 2018
        #244
      
        
        I read your post, and you did opine it could be a set up...so it is their fault
        Demsrule86
        Apr 2018
        #251
      
        
        Its not up to the men to prove they had a right to be there or that racism was a motive for their
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #259
      
        
        You are so wrong. They were politely waiting for their friend to order. At my Starbucks people sit
        Oppaloopa
        Apr 2018
        #273
      
        
        Well guess what it appears...corporate doesn't agree with you in either the Starbucks case
        Demsrule86
        Apr 2018
        #242
      
        
        I am not insulting you...but we both now the 'tresspass' thing has been used for years to keep
        Demsrule86
        Apr 2018
        #282
      
        
        How much of the police response was affected by the fact that the initial 911 call
        pnwmom
        Apr 2018
        #266
      
        
        Yeah, but like I said, police see crimes committed every day that they decide to let go.
        pnwmom
        Apr 2018
        #272
      
        
        Hah! And that will be easily provable since at least one person videotaped the arrest. n/t
        pnwmom
        Apr 2018
        #302
      
        
        Correct !! and what if the two men owned the that store ?! The police going on the managers
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #52
      
        
        The police did act stupidly, the two men in Philly could've owned the store and arresting them
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #51
      
        
        This is not the case with multi owned franchises, store managers rarely meet the owners ...
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #66
      
        
        Yep, all they had to do is look around.The PPD had the opportunity to do so and decided not to
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #78
      
        
        "There is real racism out there. I don't see it here." How do you define "real racism?"
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #316
      
        
        "The employee isn't a lawyer." Exactly. Which is why police don't arrest people just on her say so
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #315
      
        
        Store owners have no legal right to make customers leave unless they're violating a lawful condition
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #314
      
        
        Yes, asking them to leave not assessing the situation via witness's. Again, the police should
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #77
      
        
        But all of that reflects on the manager's actions, not those of the police.
        ExciteBike66
        Apr 2018
        #101
      
        
        Yeah, I've gotten that. 'I didn't see it when I was growing up. ' Really?  You were raised in a box?
        byronius
        Apr 2018
        #47
      
        
        Same way I'm shocked by examples of misogyny since I benefit from the patriarchy
        IronLionZion
        Apr 2018
        #195
      
        
        that racist bastard soiling the people's house has allowed all the scum to crawl out from
        niyad
        Apr 2018
        #10
      
        
        Exactly what hitler did.  I just watched a series on him.  Racism was his first point of attack.
        notdarkyet
        Apr 2018
        #12
      
        
        Add another thing to the LONG & GROWING list of things you CANNOT do while black ....
        LenaBaby61
        Apr 2018
        #11
      
        
        Again, an example of how cops aren't required to arrest people just because a manager calls them.
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #18
      
        
        The issue is the cops assessing the situation at Starbucks, they failed to IMHO and allowed the
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #59
      
        
        Not taking in the account of the people that were there and there are plenty of white
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #74
      
        
        The cops shouldn't ask someone to leave based off of obviously racist reasons either and if they
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #81
      
        
        But Effie didn't you hear 'all they had to do was buy a cup of coffee' (sarcasm).
        Demsrule86
        Apr 2018
        #246
      
        
        And then guess how many jellybeans in the jar - or was it how many bubbles in a bar of soap?
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #252
      
        
        Right !! I don't see how this is not obvious. They could've asked why are you wanting these
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #99
      
        
        Don't we have some amendments where people can't be arrested etc based off race?
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #141
      
        
        Lee, your first statement is overtly false ... the decision to kick them out was based off race and
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #161
      
        
        Thx for this info, sounds like since there was no posting of the rules then there was no rules that
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #169
      
        
        Please ask these people to leave because they're black is not OK nor is any other indication
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #106
      
        
        Under Pennsylvania law, they had every right to be there unless the public was put on notice
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #120
      
        
        It helps to have an understanding of something when you lecture others about it.
        ehrnst
        Apr 2018
        #135
      
        
        OK but it is not the job of the police to determine if those conditions are met
        Egnever
        Apr 2018
        #181
      
        
        Like the folks at the lunch counter in Greensboro during the Civil Rights movement?
        ehrnst
        Apr 2018
        #192
      
        
        hmmmmm, good point ... if the reasons aren't posted then how in the hell are they supposed to know!?
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #145
      
        
        +1, I think this ends this debate on whether the police took the right steps. I ASSumed the rules
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #174
      
        
        If you insist on arguing the law with a lawyer and law professor who taught Con Law, Crim Pro and
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #206
      
        
        Purchasing is NOT a store wide policy, nor was it the policy of that particular stor
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #215
      
        
        To your point it, looks like Starbucks doesn't have policy towards bathroom (link inside)
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #222
      
        
        Yet people are still telling me, right on this "Democratic" board, that it's our imagination
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #280
      
        
        It wasn't store policy because Starbucks hasn't given one (per Starbucks) link inside
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #220
      
        
        They were asked to leave because of their skin color we both know that and the police could've
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #123
      
        
        The managers decision WAS based on race and that was assessable by relevant witness's
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #164
      
        
        Now you're trashing the Starbuck's CEO as being only concerned with "the bottom line"
        ehrnst
        Apr 2018
        #172
      
        
        The manager who called seeing she had good reasons to press them right? tia
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #144
      
        
        Why should they leave...as other customers pointed out they had done nothing wrong...why do
        Demsrule86
        Apr 2018
        #237
      
        
        People sit in Starbucks for hours without buying anything. This was about racism...and
        Demsrule86
        Apr 2018
        #253
      
        
        "The employee was being racist full stop. That has nothing to do with the cops or their actions."
        BumRushDaShow
        Apr 2018
        #277
      
        
        so white folks use the bathroom which happened during the incident without buy...but these guys who
        Demsrule86
        Apr 2018
        #285
      
        
        When the other motivations are OBVIOUS but not stated then what should the police do. Thx in advance
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #133
      
        
        That argument was made in the South during the Jim Crow days...and it is used
        Demsrule86
        Apr 2018
        #236
      
        
        +1, the cops still have to assess a situation not just take someones word for it
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #56
      
        
        There were no rules posted therefore the cops had no reason to remove the two black men.
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #177
      
        
        The "You're a Special Kind of Stupid Award" goes to LA Fitness and its management.  n/t
        sarge43
        Apr 2018
        #19
      
        
        I love the comment by the officer in your last sentence.  Good for him.  And you're right...
        George II
        Apr 2018
        #49
      
        
        Are LA Fitness gyms franchises, or are they all owned by the parent company?
        Brother Buzz
        Apr 2018
        #53
      
        
        Is this crap becoming more prevalent because of Trump, being caught on video, or a combination
        argyl
        Apr 2018
        #63
      
        
        I'm sure he gave racist tendencies voice in the conscience of some Americans
        uponit7771
        Apr 2018
        #68
      
        
        "I do wish I'd had the chance to go to school with and have African American friends as a child."
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #71
      
        
        yes but alot more action needs to be taken to ensure this crap doesn't happen any more
        onetexan
        Apr 2018
        #184
      
        
        A coworker in a different department enlightened several of us in my group last week.
        MissB
        Apr 2018
        #271
      
        
        According to quite a few people in DU, theres nothing to stop because it doesnt exist
        EffieBlack
        Apr 2018
        #260
      
        
        Nope, feel worse. Liberals who haven't noticed the racism all around (and even within) them are not
        Nitram
        Apr 2018
        #298
      
        
        Cancelling my membership first thing in the morning, after I get all the facts.
        ecstatic
        Apr 2018
        #267
      
        
        I cannot understand the problem with his membership, but filming or photography is prohibited.
        Tipperary
        Apr 2018
        #294
      
        
        Aside from all this friggin racism, is anyone else annoyed that these dumbassess
        tulipsandroses
        Apr 2018
        #310
      
  