Dad's birthday cake

[MissMillie]

It's a chocolate cake with a vanilla buttercream frosting.

The crumble on top is some cookies I made that didn't come out right. (They were no-bake chocolate/peanut butter/oatmeal cookies.) There's some crumble in the middle too.

[AllaN01Bear]

1. mmmmm

[Emile]

2. Looks really delicious 😋

[MLAA]

3. He will love it! Looks wonderful.

[GreenWave]

4. Did you mean, any dad, I hope.

[japple]

5. Gorgeous cake! It sounds delicious. Hope it was enjoyed by all.

Happy Birthday to your Dad.

[Retrograde]

6. My father always had pie for his birthday

He was a chemist at a large food manufacturing company, and part of his job was analyzing cakes to make sure their profiles matched what was printed on the boxes. He would bring home the tested cakes for us kids' birthdays (frosting covered up the holes where he took the samples), but for his own he insisted on a pie - usually a strawberry pie.

[MissMillie]

7. my twin and I both LOVE peach pie

When my mom was alive she would make it for our birthday

[BobTheSubgenius]

8. I've known "birthday pie" enthusiasts over the years.

One, my own son. I am totally on the fence about this, and would say that it depends on the cake or the pie in question.

Back in my Sugar Is No Problem days, I made a Ferrero Rocher cake, and a Nanaimo Bar Cake that a lot of people would have trouble resisting and might even convert a few "pie people."