Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

debm55

(51,580 posts)
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 01:51 PM Oct 4

Leaves are changing colors, temps are getting lower, But I think of Fall as apple time. My favorite is Granny Smith

crisp and tart. What is your favorite apple?

67 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Leaves are changing colors, temps are getting lower, But I think of Fall as apple time. My favorite is Granny Smith (Original Post) debm55 Oct 4 OP
Granny Smith, Red Delicious, Gala SheltieLover Oct 4 #1
Thank you very much for your selections. SheltieLover. Enjoy. debm55 Oct 4 #4
Gala for me Bluestocking Oct 4 #2
Thank you very much, Bluestocking. Enjoy, debm55 Oct 4 #5
Cameo for me. sueh Oct 4 #3
Thank you very much for your selection, sueh. Enjoy. debm55 Oct 4 #7
Thanks, Deb! sueh Oct 4 #11
Ashmead's Kernel Keepthesoulalive Oct 4 #6
Thank you very much, Keepthesoulalive. Enjoy your Ashead"s Kernel debm55 Oct 4 #8
Red delicious off my backyard tree rurallib Oct 4 #9
Thank you very much, rurallib. Enjoy your apples. debm55 Oct 4 #12
I'm sorry al bupp Oct 4 #10
Thank you al bubb. That you for selection of Gala. Enjoy. debm55 Oct 4 #14
🍎🍎Northern Spy, Hands Down!! 🍎🍎 justaprogressive Oct 4 #13
Thank you, justaprogressive for your wonderful post of the Northern spy apple. They look delicious. Enjoy. debm55 Oct 4 #15
They (the spies) aren't ripe for picking yet... justaprogressive Oct 4 #22
Thank you very much, justaprogressive. Enjoy when they are ripe. Until then, enjoy your McIntosh. debm55 Oct 4 #27
Have you tried "Ambrosia" Apples? no_hypocrisy Oct 4 #16
No I haven't, no-hypocrisy. We are going to our local farm I will see if they have any. Thank you for the suggestion. debm55 Oct 4 #19
Best apple I've found is only available in fall-- Arkansas Black. And with rare exception, I still eat one apple a day. Silent Type Oct 4 #17
HAHAHAHHAHah. Thank you very much, Silent Type. I will look for them, debm55 Oct 4 #20
In one of the apple charts I mention (post #31).... electric_blue68 Oct 4 #34
Yes, I noticed that they were very dark. Thank you. debm55 Oct 4 #59
Honeycrisp or Pink Lady. Ritabert Oct 4 #18
Love the names. That you very much for suggesting them to us. debm55 Oct 4 #21
I always liked Jonathon apples as a kid, MIButterfly Oct 4 #23
Wow, that is a lot.Thank you MIButterfly. and enjoy your red delicious apples. debm55 Oct 4 #25
Pink Lady for me. Polly Hennessey Oct 4 #24
Thank you very much Polly Hennessey. Enjoy your Pink Lady. debm55 Oct 4 #26
Caramel Apple ;-{) Goonch Oct 4 #28
HAHAHHAHHAHAHAH. Oh you. debm55 Oct 4 #29
Winesap (heirloom), honeycrisp, red delicious.... electric_blue68 Oct 4 #30
Thank you very much. electric_blue68. debm55 Oct 4 #43
There are fun charts showing apples from sweetest to most tart. electric_blue68 Oct 4 #31
Here's a chart Nittersing Oct 4 #37
And there's the Arkansas Black. 👍 electric_blue68 Oct 4 #40
Thank you very much, Nittersing. I love it. debm55 Oct 4 #53
Cosmic Crisp or Juici. boonecreek Oct 4 #32
Thank you very much, boonecreek. Those are great combos to find in an apple. I like crunch and tart. debm55 Oct 4 #51
Honeycrisp. catbyte Oct 4 #33
Thank you very much, catbyte. That's hot for Michigan this time of year isn't it? debm55 Oct 4 #50
Yes, yes it is. The a/c just kicked on at 9:05 pm. In October. catbyte Oct 4 #64
Hope it cools down for you. debm55 Sunday #66
I love Johnathon apples Alliepoo Oct 4 #35
Thank you very much, Alliepoo. debm55 Oct 4 #49
Cosmic Crisp is amazing! Phoenix61 Oct 4 #36
Oh nuts, They sound delicious. Thank you Phoenix61, debm55 Oct 4 #48
Mutsu! johnp3907 Oct 4 #38
Thank you very much for your selections. johnp3907 debm55 Oct 4 #47
Red Delicious all the way kozar Oct 4 #39
Thank you very much, kozar. Enjoy them. debm55 Oct 4 #46
Macoun beemerphill Oct 4 #41
Thank you very much, beemerphill for your selection. debm55 Oct 4 #45
Granny Smith By A Mile ProfessorGAC Oct 4 #42
I agree. Thank you very much, ProfessorGAC and enjoy your apple. debm55 Oct 4 #44
By The Way... ProfessorGAC Oct 4 #54
I'll trade you ---we have fallen leaves all over the yard. I don't think it was as hot in Pittsburgh as in the Chicago debm55 Oct 4 #56
Delicious. delicious and sweet riversedge Oct 4 #52
Cortland although can be difficult to find in WA state. GP6971 Oct 4 #55
Honey Crisp, Gala, Braeburn, Jonagold (cross b/w Jonathan & Golden Delicious). But for making apple pie, Granny Smith is KitFox Oct 4 #57
Thank you very much, KitFox, Your selection is great.I add apple chips to my salads. Yum. I always liked Granny Smith. debm55 Oct 4 #63
Honeycrisp or Fuji. Diamond_Dog Oct 4 #58
Thank you very much, Diamond_Dog. Enjoy. debm55 Oct 4 #60
the day afterr i had my bday, i went to an apple orcherd to have breakfast at their restraunt. AllaN01Bear Oct 4 #61
That sounds wonderful. Thank you very much, Bear, debm55 Oct 4 #62
Mine too malaise Sunday #65
Thank you very much, malaise. and enjoy, debm55 Sunday #67

justaprogressive

(5,635 posts)
13. 🍎🍎Northern Spy, Hands Down!! 🍎🍎
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 02:06 PM
Oct 4


Northern Spy apples, botanically classified as Malus domestica, are an heirloom American variety belonging to the Rosaceae family. The late-season fruits grow on trees reaching 3 to 4.8 meters in height and are an all-purpose variety utilized for fresh recipes, cooked preparations, and cider processing. Northern Spy apples were developed in the early 19th century in New York and quickly became a favored variety for home gardens as the trees were easy-to-grow, vigorous, and somewhat hardy. The apples were also cold tolerant, surviving for extended periods, providing a fresh food source during the bleak northeastern winters. Throughout history, Northern Spy apples have become a symbol of Americana. In 1953, the Toronto Globe and Mail sent Northern Spy apples to Senator Joseph McCarthy as a joke during McCarthy's hunt for communist spies. Allegations were being made of spies in Canada, so the Canadian news outlet sent the spy apples to McCarty, which was met with McCarthy holding the apples and laughing, captured in a famous photo. "Spies for pies!" was another well-known slogan throughout the American baking scene in the 19th and early 20th centuries, with many bakers refusing to use any other variety for their homemade creations. Northern Spy apples remained a treasured American fruit into the 21st century, even after they departed from the commercial spotlight. In 2013, the variety was one of four apples honored by the United States Postal Service and was placed on commemorative stamps designed by artist John Burgoyne. In the modern day, Northern Spy Apples are valued for their crisp texture and sharp flavor and are most famous for their use in pies and ciders.

There are several legends behind the apple's name, but in true espionage fashion, the answer is thought to have self-destructed with its creators and remains shrouded in mystery. The first theory points to the Chapin family's history as soldiers. The Chapin family's founder Deacon Samuel Chapin was one of the early settlers of the Massachusetts Bay Colony in the early 1630s. His bloodline continued throughout American history, including connections to President Grover Cleveland and William H. Taft, abolitionist Henry Ward Beecher, and Poet T.S. Eliot. The Chapin family also had several famous soldiers and war leaders, including General Israel Chapin. It is thought the name Northern Spy apples was taken from an 1821 book written by James Fennimore Cooper entitled The Spy: A Tale of the Neutral Ground. The novel's plot involves a man spying on the British during the Revolutionary War. Legend has it the book was inspired by John Jay, a revolutionary who helped form the U.S. counterintelligence. John Jay was a friend and colleague of General Israel Chapin, thus tying together the theory that Northern Spy may have been derived from the Chapin family's involvement and close relations to various members of secret intelligence. The other leading theory connects the apple's name to a written piece that was circulated among abolitionists in the 1830s. This piece told the story of a "Northern Spy" who established safehouses to transport slaves from Virginia to New York. The spy would impersonate a slave catcher and would usher slaves to safety, killing leaders in the pro-slavery movement. Much of the history of this written piece is unknown, but it was said to have later inspired the book written by J. Thomas Warren called The Northern Spy: The Fatal Papers.



debm55

(51,580 posts)
15. Thank you, justaprogressive for your wonderful post of the Northern spy apple. They look delicious. Enjoy.
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 02:11 PM
Oct 4

justaprogressive

(5,635 posts)
22. They (the spies) aren't ripe for picking yet...
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 02:55 PM
Oct 4

they're almost the last species to ripen 2nd-3rd week in October...

munching and pie-ing on McIntosh while we wait...

debm55

(51,580 posts)
27. Thank you very much, justaprogressive. Enjoy when they are ripe. Until then, enjoy your McIntosh.
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 03:14 PM
Oct 4

no_hypocrisy

(53,364 posts)
16. Have you tried "Ambrosia" Apples?
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 02:15 PM
Oct 4

I saw some in North Carolina 2 weeks ago.

I should have bought some at the Orchard.

debm55

(51,580 posts)
19. No I haven't, no-hypocrisy. We are going to our local farm I will see if they have any. Thank you for the suggestion.
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 02:38 PM
Oct 4

Silent Type

(11,394 posts)
17. Best apple I've found is only available in fall-- Arkansas Black. And with rare exception, I still eat one apple a day.
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 02:31 PM
Oct 4

electric_blue68

(24,226 posts)
34. In one of the apple charts I mention (post #31)....
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 03:52 PM
Oct 4

one has the Arkansas Black, and , wow, it is practically black!
Probably a saturated combo of the red & green coloring.

MIButterfly

(1,477 posts)
23. I always liked Jonathon apples as a kid,
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 02:56 PM
Oct 4

but they've gotten harder and harder to find over the years. Now I buy red delicious apples. My mother liked Gala and Honeycrisp apples. I went to the store one time and one of them (I forgot which) was $2.99 a pound. I bought two and it cost me $8.00! Yikes! My mother always did have expensive taste.

🍎 🍏 🍎 🍏 🍎 🍏 🍎 🍏 🍎 🍏 🍎 🍏 🍎

electric_blue68

(24,226 posts)
30. Winesap (heirloom), honeycrisp, red delicious....
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 03:44 PM
Oct 4

sometimes granny smith.

And, yes, the name winesap alludes to a mild winey flavor. Not found in stores, it's a green market find, and where I found it. 👍
So far it's unique in taste.

ETA:
There are two more varieties, one being the Stayman Winesap. I think waaay back I saw Staymans. Maybe they dropped the "winesap" label part.

And it turns out The Delicious started to replace it in the 1950's for tolerating warmer weather. Never had a RD that had a winey undertone.

debm55

(51,580 posts)
51. Thank you very much, boonecreek. Those are great combos to find in an apple. I like crunch and tart.
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 07:25 PM
Oct 4

catbyte

(37,995 posts)
33. Honeycrisp.
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 03:51 PM
Oct 4

They're good for both eating and cooking. Very versatile.

I wish it felt more like fall -- it's 88F, I'm all out of the mood, lol.

Phoenix61

(18,582 posts)
36. Cosmic Crisp is amazing!
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 04:02 PM
Oct 4

It’s a cross between a Honeycrisp and an Enterprise developed by Washington State University. At present they can only be grown in Washington State.

ProfessorGAC

(74,752 posts)
42. Granny Smith By A Mile
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 06:12 PM
Oct 4

I've had other apple types I liked, but nothing beats that tart pop of a GS apple.

ProfessorGAC

(74,752 posts)
54. By The Way...
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 07:29 PM
Oct 4

...we had such a warm September that our leaves aren't turning yet!
Not even the pin oak.
I'm going to be out there collecting leaves with a winter coat!
I wish they were turning colors. That's a cool time of year.

debm55

(51,580 posts)
56. I'll trade you ---we have fallen leaves all over the yard. I don't think it was as hot in Pittsburgh as in the Chicago
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 07:36 PM
Oct 4

area. However, it was very dry here. This last week, we had to cut down three of my Japanese fire trees, And the grass is like hay.

KitFox

(441 posts)
57. Honey Crisp, Gala, Braeburn, Jonagold (cross b/w Jonathan & Golden Delicious). But for making apple pie, Granny Smith is
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 07:38 PM
Oct 4

the best. I like adding apples to some salads. I love this time of year! ❤️🍎🍏🧡😊

debm55

(51,580 posts)
63. Thank you very much, KitFox, Your selection is great.I add apple chips to my salads. Yum. I always liked Granny Smith.
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 08:43 PM
Oct 4

AllaN01Bear

(27,592 posts)
61. the day afterr i had my bday, i went to an apple orcherd to have breakfast at their restraunt.
Sat Oct 4, 2025, 08:17 PM
Oct 4

the apples were turning a nice from green to red color.

malaise

(290,020 posts)
65. Mine too
Sun Oct 5, 2025, 09:01 AM
Sunday

The thing is I never buy imported fruit so I only have them when I visit countries where they grow.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Leaves are changing color...