General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe crowd size numbers are beginning to come in:
https://open.substack.com/pub/politicususanews/p/massive-crowd-numbers-are-beginning?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=3aksqTwenty million people protested for Earth Day in 1970 in the United States. The only other protests to come close to Earth Day 1970 were the George Floyd protests. It is possible that No Kings (October) could end up being the second-largest single-day protest in US history.
A better estimate likely wont be available until Sunday, but the low-end estimate for today currently is that 6 million people will end up attending these protests. The high-end number will be around 10 million.
Either of those numbers would make the fall No Kings protest the second-largest single-day political protest in US history.

NoMoreRepugs
(11,684 posts)participate should be ashamed. Sorry, Im just pissed that number isnt 20MILLION+.
Traildogbob
(12,053 posts)Meant more to many.
QueerDuck
(272 posts)... Someone not going to a protest or really does not mean that they do not care, or that they have not made a difference in other ways. Nor does it mean that they have the means, ability, or capability to attend. My reasons for not going are nobody's business but my own and it's unfair to try and shame me (or anyone.)
speak easy
(12,487 posts)queue musical accompaniment
Charming. Nobody can bully me either.
But that's a good version... Not as good as Michael Buble or Julie London.
AZ8theist
(6,936 posts)I don't think NMR meant to shame anyone here, just angry there wasn't an overwhelming presence.
Hell, I'm disapointed there wasn't 100+ MILLION protesting these fucking Nazis.
But some of us, like myself, have a difficult time walking due to various ailments, so our protest days are behind us now.
Just as much, or more, can be accomplished from the background. Contributions to better candidates, emailing congress, participating in local elections, etc. Holding people accoutable.
However, that being said, I would certainly be ashamed if people couldn't be bothered to VOTE when our democracy itself is on the line.
QueerDuck
(272 posts)... It seems that mockery and ridicule and fake pity are all the rage these days. 🙄🤪
Botany
(75,612 posts)
QueerDuck
(272 posts)Trueblue Texan
(3,897 posts)We all have different abilities, talents, and ideas about what makes our own contribution valuable. I respect everyone who participates in the resistance, whether it's the same way I do it or not.
cab67
(3,512 posts)AllyCat
(18,285 posts)I went in June.
Sorry. I wish more had gone too. Some of us cannot.
Oeditpus Rex
(43,040 posts)I can walk naybe 100 feet before pain in my sacrum and quadriceps overcomes me, and the bus stop is about 300 yards away.
Should I feel ashaned?
WhiskeyGrinder
(25,869 posts)NoMoreRepugs
(11,684 posts)Try to leave weekly messages for my congressmaga Rutherford that he needs to get off his ass and oppose the fascist takeover of America. Donate to those D candidates I deem worthy.
WhiskeyGrinder
(25,869 posts)Conjuay
(2,760 posts)Thanks for the guilt trip.
mwmisses4289
(2,491 posts)Not all of us could get time off to go to the protests.
ironman99
(137 posts)I had a choice, attend a demonstration or be with my wife who had her knee replaced the day before. Don't lump everyone into one basket!!!!!!!!!
CanonRay
(15,700 posts)70sEraVet
(5,017 posts)LAS14
(15,371 posts)70sEraVet
(5,017 posts)MichMan
(16,118 posts)Current US population is 342 million, so the number participating today is between 2-3%
mountain grammy
(28,345 posts)and a bit depressing.
Response to mountain grammy (Reply #17)
Skittles This message was self-deleted by its author.
LAS14
(15,371 posts)... protests in other countries put the critical participation at 5%. SEE YOU ALL NEXT JUNE!!!!
Skittles
(168,201 posts)a LOT of people are afraid to get out there and PISS OFF these fascist FREAKS
hatrack
(63,800 posts).....I doubt that the Earth Day protestors had to be concerned that their own government might arrest them for exercising their freedom of speech.
Or that the supporters of the president might harm them.
Or that the Speaker of the House and Cabinet members might stir up hatred (& potential violence) against them by labeling the Earth Day protestors as domestic terrorists, as we have experienced in this era.
I, too, would love the No Kings numbers to be even bigger, but I think there were some people who stayed home for fear for their personal safety. I think we should feel really good about the turnout, though!
(This is Mrs. Hatrack, hijacking Hatrack's account. Looks like some others made the same point while I was typing this.)
yardwork
(68,354 posts)I didn't know these were characterized as protests. We played outdoor games, made tee shirts, etc.
Anyway, I think a lot of scout troops and other youth organizations participated in Earth Day 1970 - the very first Earth Day. It was a celebration of the earth and nature, maybe with a little bit of protest mixed in.
Hope22
(4,233 posts)Or bated by the Speaker of the House. Yesterday Maggots were asked to strike out against the haters of the US but didnt why not? Because the last fools that listened to them on J6th lost their jobs, homes, families and were locked up until they got their pardons. In the past ICE was not lurking to grab anyone they wanted. This right here, is a whole new world.i have no real idea why the crazy maggots didnt shoot or drive into the crowds. Im very thankful for the success that we had. Every march I attend I know there is a possibility of being harmed by the crackpots. Many citizens here are broken by the stress of it all. Getting hurt out there for many means no access to healthcare and loss of jobs. We dont know who has marched or stood when and should not make judgments. Yesterday was a great showing and people did the best they could! For a march in Nazi America I think this one holds the record!
yardwork
(68,354 posts)1WorldHope
(1,725 posts)Oneironaut
(6,137 posts)I expected 20 or so. It ended up being 20x that or more.
electric_blue68
(24,452 posts)Oppaloopa
(926 posts)flamingdem
(40,718 posts)that means social change can be effectuated
LAS14
(15,371 posts)applegrove
(128,881 posts)soldiers balk at attacking a crowd of their countrymen.
Hope22
(4,233 posts)Than the number of Americans willing and able to defend their family and homes. If soldiers are coming door to door when they wage their proclaimed war against the people I think they will be surprised at what they will be up against.
Bernardo de La Paz
(59,737 posts)There is a reference in my Journal around the time of June I think.
Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin
(129,962 posts)No sure how they arrived at the number but there were more people at this event than the one in June.
CentralMass
(16,618 posts)Morbius
(747 posts)It's about getting the message across that we're pissed, and we're not gonna take it.
Never did, and never will.
They can publicly scoff but they're quaking in their loafers, no matter what they say.
Scrivener7
(57,487 posts)
NoMoreRepugs
(11,684 posts)Hope22
(4,233 posts)Why not support the great efforts of the marchers yesterday and focus divisive discussion on the magas. Everyone does their best!
BlueWaveNeverEnd
(11,774 posts)Sparkly
(24,769 posts)
calimary
(88,178 posts)Hope they get bigger and broader-based. Its a BIG morale-booster!
Ocelot II
(127,873 posts)That's from CBS and Fox affiliate reports. That's a New York number, and in a city with a total population of not quite 430,000, so I guess we beat the 3.5% rule by a bit. (The 3.5% rule is a concept in political science that states that when 3.5% of the population of a country protest nonviolently against a government, that government is likely to fall from power. Of course, the GOP doesn't have much power here anyhow). The metro area has 3.7 million so maybe that's optimistic, and obviously many folks came in from the 'burbs. But still, it's a great turnout. And the 'burbs had eight or so of their own protests.
NoSheep
(8,308 posts)I am unable to stand for a long period due to physical issues. There must be lots of people like me who are afraid and disgusted and who want to be out there but cannot for one reason or another.
Borogove
(245 posts)Columbia County, where Bloomsburg is located, is a very red area.
Ol Janx Spirit
(436 posts)...report the number of checks he wrote on Saturday?
Rs totally misrepresenting these protests as paid events and protesters as hating America are making a huge mistake. Nothing from any of the protests suggests the alternate reality they are trying to push--undermining their credibility even more if it is possible.
It is also not fair to compare the Earth Day event in 1970 for several reasons: For one it was--and still is--an outlier event. The largest protest in America before that day is considered to be the 1963 March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom which drew an estimated 500,000 people. And for another it was preceded by the clear impacts of 150 years of industrial development that had finally begun to show up in the daily lives of the average American which encouraged all kinds of groups to unite in common cause. And for another--as has been pointed out here--there was no perception that demonstrating in support of the environment would cause an immediate backlash by government officials--it would take decades for corporate interests to have their revenge through lobbying.
"No Kings" yesterday was an incredible display of solidarity against this regime after only a few months of giving us its worst. And we can take heart in the fact that these events are happening everywhere: in big blue cities and in little red towns! Like it or not, everyone sees what they are doing and will eventually be forced to speak out if they want to keep the way of life America has cobbled together since its inception.